Accelerating GPU Performance
GPU computational performance can surpass hybrid CPU/GPU, even for small matrix sizes if host synchronization were eliminated using CUDAGraphs.
By default, GPU operations are asynchronous; however, host synchronization forces the CPU (host) to wait for the completion of GPU operations before proceeding. The result is a blocking operation that eliminates the natural asynchronous parallelism between CPU and GPU.
Host synchronization impairs performance in GPU computing. Any approach with frequent host sync points (like hybrid CPU/GPU strategies) will severely degrade performance, regardless of how fast individual operators are. By extrapolation, end-to-end pipeline design and CUDAGraph compatibility provide better performance metrics than isolated operator benchmarks.
Host synchronization can occur for several reasons including accessing GPU tensor values, moving data to CPU, explicit synchronization calls, and memory operations across devices. These benchmarks showed the dramatic impact of isolated GPU operations: 1.053ms compared to realistic host syncs: 9.867ms (9.4× slower!). The hybrid CPU/GPU approaches are problematic yielding a 14.9% performance overhead from constant device switching that are 1.44× slower than GPU-only pipeline.
CUDAGraphs capture the entire computation graph and eliminate per-operation host synchronization. Furthermore, torch.compile (mode="reduce-overhead") automatically reduces host synchronization through:
* Batching kernel launches with fewer sync points
* Kernel fusion where multiple operations become a single GPU call
* Memory pool pre-allocation that eliminates allocation syncs
* Graph optimization that minimizes host-device communication
Performance improved 2.78× for element-wise operations with torch.compile and reduced the number of host synchronization points.
Conclusion:
Host synchronization is the hidden performance killer in GPU computing. Any approach that introduces frequent host sync points (like hybrid CPU/GPU strategies) severely degrades performance, irrespective of individual operators speed. Therefore, end-to-end pipeline design and CUDAGraph compatibility are more important than isolated operator benchmarks. GPU computing can outperform hybrid CPU/GPU using CUDAGraphs and torch.compile with reduce-overhead.
Source Code References
The comprehensive analysis was conducted using these benchmark scripts (now in the pytorch-testing-scripts repository):
https://lnkd.in/gjbV3AbJ - Complete benchmarking suite with CUDAGraph and torch.compile support
e2e_benchmark_clean.py - End-to-end analysis demonstrating host synchronization impact
Repository: https://lnkd.in/gqUuiv2G
Thanks for sharing! We have a question on deep-ml where you could try and implement GRPO from scratch to see if you truly understand it https://www.deep-ml.com/problems/101