Pivot or Peril: Are Canadian Cities Diversifying or Doubling Down on America? Today, the Business Data Lab (BDL) released new analysis examining which Canadian cities are successfully diversifying beyond the U.S. market, and which remain highly exposed to U.S. trade disruption and are now showing signs of local economic stress. The findings suggest Canada’s trade diversification is real, but highly uneven and concentrated. Some key findings: • Calgary, Ottawa–Gatineau, Toronto, Saskatoon and Kelowna are among the CMAs making the strongest gains in non-U.S. export diversification • Oshawa, London and Kitchener-Cambridge-Waterloo are among the regions showing some of the clearest signs of trade-related economic stress • What looks like diversification is actually concentration: non-U.S. exports rose 17%, but the number of exporters increased far less – suggesting existing exporters are driving most of the gains, rather than new firms entering global markets. • Roughly 90% of non-exporting businesses still describe themselves as “local” in nature The broader takeaway: diversification is increasingly becoming a resilience strategy – not just a growth strategy. Canada does not just need more trade. It needs more traders. That’s one reason why BDL is currently developing a new trade diversification tool designed to help Canadian businesses better identify international market opportunities and understand where their products may already be competitive globally. Read the full analysis below. Thanks to Jasleen Kaur Trehan for collaborating with me on the analysis. FYI: Canadian Chamber of Commerce, Catherine Fortin LeFaivre (elle/she/her), Shane Mackenzie, Matthew Holmes, Economic Developers Association of Canada (EDAC), John Perrott, Daniel Caramori, Xavier Roy, Ruhee Ismail-Teja, MPP, Stephanie Naday, Margot Orr-Stevenson, Saad Usmani, George Greenwood, MBA, CPA, CFP, Federation of Canadian Municipalities, Mark Rendell, Brett Chang https://lnkd.in/ezKvy-dW #Trade #TradeDiversification #CanadaUS #CanadianEconomy #Exports #SMEs #EconomicDevelopment #SupplyChains #TradePolicy #EconomicResilience #BusinessData #Productivity #CdnBiz #CDNPoli #GlobalTrade #Manufacturing #ServicesTrade #BusinessDataLab #CanadianChamber
I guess Calgary is being more diversified because we have seen a greater share of oil exports going to non-US destination thanks to TMX. However, that oil is not extracted in Calgary. It's only the head offices that are in Calgary, while the extraction is done 800km North, where a lot of the jobs are. I'm not sure how we solve that measurement problem: location of the reporting entity vs where the activity takes place.
To paraphrase what Thierry Warin wrote in one of his papers: jurisdictions don't trade, firms do. The inability of certain firms to shift their trade patterns likely reflects ownership structures (i.e., US subsidiaries) or supply-chain dynamics that can't easily be overcome in the short-term.