[Non-issue/Minor issue] Dynamic filtering precedence confusion #1748
Comments
The cell at If this really confuses a majority of users, I will just remove the ability to create block rules for images. The primary purpose of |
I guess that is not really required though it would be nice to add/update examples at: For example:
Is that Also a statement:
implies that a below dynamic filter rule would not work? This one is confusing too since it is present in the rules but does not work. Edit:
It seems Still blocks behind-the-scene requests. Despite:
|
|
I have a similar/the same problem. I left a Medium article open, and noticed uBlock blocked ~300k requests, so I investigated. Turns out that the webpage connects to First I tried various dynamic rules, ending up with the following permanent dynamic rule: The docs seem pretty clear this rule should override the static ones, but that doesn't work. |
Your rule works fine here. Did you enable Advanced user mode? |
|
@gorhill You're right, I didn't and that fixed it, but the UI/docs doesn't tell me to in places I looked at. The "My rules" settings page is shown without that enabled, and neither that settings page nor the page linked at "full documentation" (https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dynamic-filtering:-rule-syntax) dynamic page mentions it. (I didn't find an edit button for the wiki, so I'm afraid some contributor will have to fix it). Would you like a separate issue for that? |
No. This is a sub page on the whole topic -- go back to the main page and it's clearly mentioned. |
|
Could I then suggest linking to https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/Dynamic-filtering instead? (I'd also say the Dynamic filtering page should at least have a warning if it's disabled, to be a bit more usable, but changing the link is easier and would make things much better). |
It does already link back, that's what I pointed out in my answer above. |
|
Ok I see, you mean from the dashboard of uBO itself. |


Requirements:
Reproducing steps:
addons.mozilla.org * image noopis present in a dynamic filter.Additional information:
I do realize that
3phas a precedence over animagetype but it is a bit confusing. Sinceaddons.mozilla.org * image nooprule does coexist in a dynamic filter with* * 3p block. Although in my opinion* * 3p blockis being less specific thanaddons.mozilla.org * image noop. An intended behavior?Good luck fixing that.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: