Return to Answer

In the TOS Book The Kobayashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Kobayashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fail" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses his mathematical and engineering know how to destroy wave after wave of attacking Klingon vessels. One of the techniques he uses is known not to work in practice, but because theoretically it should, the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes on what passing the Kobayashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've mis-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.

In the TOS Book The Kobayashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Kobayashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fail" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses his mathematical and engineering knowhow to destroy wave after wave of attacking Klingon vessels. One of the techniques he uses is known not to work in practice, but because theoretically it should, the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes on what passing the Kobayashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've mis-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.

In the TOS Book The Koboyashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Koboyashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fail" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses mathematical engineering know how to destroy wave after wave of Klingon ships attacking to Koboyashi Maru. The technique he uses is known not to work in practice, but because mathematically it should the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes what passing the Koboyashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've miss-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.

In the TOS Book The Kobayashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Kobayashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fail" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses his mathematical and engineering know how to destroy wave after wave of attacking Klingon vessels. One of the techniques he uses is known not to work in practice, but because theoretically it should, the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes on what passing the Kobayashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've mis-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.

In the TOS Book The Koboyashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Koboyashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fails" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses mathematically engineering know how to destroy wave after wave of Klingon ships attacking to Koboyashi Maru. The technique he uses is known not to work in practice, but because mathematically it should the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes what passing the Koboyashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've miss-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.

In the TOS Book The Koboyashi Maru Cadet Montgomery Scott fails the Koboyashi Maru and is moved from the Command Stream to the Engineering Stream.

"Fail" is a nuanced word however.

Scott uses mathematical engineering know how to destroy wave after wave of Klingon ships attacking to Koboyashi Maru. The technique he uses is known not to work in practice, but because mathematically it should the computer lets him use it. He "fails" the test for contempt and is moved to the Engineering Stream he really wants to be in.

The linked book is a really interesting read, with 4 different takes what passing the Koboyashi Maru actually means. Apologies if I've miss-remembered anything as it's been 25 years since I read it.