Java Methods Best Practice: Use Meaningful Return Types

Ramesh Fadatare

Follow

3 min read

·

Apr 28, 2025

--

1

Share

🧾 Introduction

Writing methods in Java is easy. But writing clean, safe, and self-explanatory methods — that’s the real art.

One key area where many developers struggle is return types. Returning random null, raw arrays, or heavy entities makes your code fragile, confusing, and error-prone.

In this article, you’ll learn how to use better return types like Optional, List, and domain-specific DTOs — with real-world examples you can apply immediately.

Also, check out:

🚩 Problem: Poor Return Types Lead to Bad Code

Returning raw types like:

• null
• empty Strings
• bare arrays (User[])
• full entities directly makes your methods:

❌ Harder to use safely
❌ Prone to NullPointerException
❌ Difficult to maintain when requirements change
❌ Less expressive about the real intent of the method

Solution: Return Types That Tell a Clear Story

✅ Use Optional<T> when a value might be absent.
✅ Use List<T>, Set<T>, or Map<K, V> instead of arrays.
✅ Use DTOs (Data Transfer Objects) to return structured, controlled responses.
✅ Avoid returning null — prefer meaningful defaults like Collections.emptyList().

By using meaningful return types, your methods become:

• Safer
• Cleaner
• Self-documenting
• Future-proof

Example 1: Use Optional Instead of Returning Null

❌ Bad Example (Returning Null)

public User findUserByEmail(String email) {
    User user = database.findByEmail(email);
    return user != null ? user : null;
}