A Thorough Examination of 2 Corinthians 5:1-4:
A Thorough Analysis of 2 Corinthians 5:1-4:
The "tent of our earthly house" is undoubtedly a reference to our material, fleshly bodies. All human beings are inherently mortal, that is, subject to death, as their bodies can be "demolished" or "thrown down" [that is what the Greek word καταλυθῇ [a form of the verb καταλύω {see Strong's G2647}] denotes), that is, "destroyed". Our "earthly houses" deteriorate and decay; they are degradable and perishable. Essentially, all physical bodies have a definite end, that is, a point in time whereby all vital functions cease to be, and the life of the person is terminated (however, this is not the end for all, particularly for believers in Christ, as we will see). The parallels between 2 Corinthians 5:1-4 and 1 Corinthians 15:35-58 are indisputable and undeniable. A common interpretation is that the apostle Paul is speaking, in v.1-4 of 2 Cor. 5, about the afterlife, namely, the intermediate state. However, we will see that such an understanding is unreasonable and that the interpretation that Paul is speaking about our resurrection bodies is much more tenable. So, v.1 parallels v.36 of 1 Cor. 15, where Paul states that what we sow "does not come to life unless it dies". V.42-44 make it clear that what is sown is our perishable, natural (physical) bodies. In v.36, Paul is making the point that our physical body (or "earthly house") cannot "come to life", that is, be raised imperishable, immortal, glorious, and powerful, unless it dies. And here, in 2 Cor. 5:1, Paul is saying that if our "earthly house" (physical body) is destroyed (dies), we have a "building from God... eternal in the heavens". Both 1 Cor. 15:36 and 2 Cor 5:1 talk about our physical bodies being destroyed, and so it is logical to conclude that the "building from God... eternal in the heavens" is a reference to our immortal, glorious, spiritual bodies given to us by God, which is precisely how our mortal bodies (that which we "sow") "come to life" in the context of 1 Cor. 15:36! There are many more parallels that make it conclusive that what Paul is teaching in v.1-4 of 2 Cor. 5 is not something different than what he teaches in 1 Cor. 15:35-58, but in fact the same thing.
Once again Paul tells us that we groan in "the tent", namely, our "earthly house" or material bodies. This is, again, no wonder. Indeed, we are burdened in this tent, as the apostle says. I am personally very fit, though the same cannot be said for many other believers, and about humanity as a whole, and even I have some difficult days body-wise. Of course, I will not be quite so fit forever! And indeed, I know many (some very close to me) who are incredibly burdened by these weak and perishable bodies. But that's for another time. The point is, the apostle Paul's words are some of the truest words; we groan, being burdened, in our fleshly tent. What Paul says next is astonishing. We groan because "we do not wish to be unclothed but to be clothed"! Indeed, we are all anxiously waiting to receive our resurrection bodies, so that we may be rid of these weak and fragile "tents" once and for all time. Unexpectedly, however, Paul tells us that we are groaning because we do not wish to be unclothed (that is, to be dead and disembodied) but to be clothed! Again, "unclothed" can only be a reference to the state of the dead, as currently we have an article of clothing, i.e. our earthly tent/house (however weak and frail this attire may be). If indeed upon death believers are transferred to an intermediate state where they experience bliss and comfort in paradise in God's presence, why would we, in our current frail, inadequate bodies that are subject to old age and disease and sinful desires, not wish to be "unclothed", that is, to be in this state (dead)? How Paul's words here, put together with all his previous words (as we have previously discussed), can be reconciled with the notion of going to paradise/Abraham's bosom upon death to be in total bliss and comfort in the presence of God and Jesus, I'll let the ones who believe in such concept to figure out.
There are several parallels here with 1 Corinthians 15. For example, Paul says that we "groan, being burdened" in these mortal bodies. Well, in verses 42 and 43 of 1 Cor. 15, Paul says that what is sown is "perishable" and sown in "dishonour" and "weakness". Without a question, one would "groan" and be "burdened" by a weak, perishable, dishonourable body. He also says here that we "wish... to be clothed". Well, in v.42-43 of 1 Cor. 15, Paul says that what is "sown" (i.e. our physical bodies, which are perishable, dishonourable, and weak) is "raised imperishable", and in "glory" and "power". I don't think anyone would argue with the assertion that theyone would wish to be "clothed" if by being clothed they are forever rid of perishability, dishonour, and weakness, and given imperishability, glory, and power! And finally, here in v.4 of 2 Cor. 5, Paul says that in being "clothed", the "mortal"mortal is "swallowed" up by life. In 1 Cor. 15:54, Paul says that when the mortal and perishable have been clothed with immortality and imperishability, the saying, "death has been swallowed up in victory", will have come to pass. Indeed, if death has been "swallowed up in victory", all that remains is life! And if mortality is "clothed" with immortality, mortality must be gone as well, since immortality and mortality are polar opposites. And since immortality is, by definition, the quality of living forever or not being subject to death, death itself must necessarily be gone forever! The point is, when death is "swallowed up" in victory, all that remains is life, which Paul tells us swallows up "the mortal" (if death is truly "swallowed up"gone for good, then mortality is necessarily "swallowed up"gone for good as well, as all that dies is, by definition, mortal).
An Analysis of 2 Corinthians 5:5-10:
An Examination of 2 Corinthians 5:5-10: